Cyntara - Forum - Elden Ring Items: 10 You Can Craft That Beat Store-Bought

Cyntara v17 Countdown

Create your character now!

UlnaPilgrims
26 Jul 25 01:45 AM
In Elden Ring, the open-world freedom to explore, fight, and craft opens up a unique advantage for players who take the time to understand the game’s item system. While merchants can offer convenience, not everything worth carrying needs to be bought. In fact, some of the most useful and cost-effective gear is just a crafting menu away.

Whether you’re managing resources in early game or prepping for endgame battles, here are 10 craftable Elden Ring items that can easily outperform what you’ll find in stores.


1. Poisonbone Arrows

These arrows, crafted from Poisonbloom and animal bones, are a budget-friendly yet deadly option, especially when facing humanoid or beast enemies with low poison resistance. They're not just cheap to make—they outperform many merchant-sold arrows by enabling slow, persistent damage.

2. Fire Pots

Instead of spending Runes on throwing pots, just craft your own. Fire Pots are reliable tools for softening enemy packs or dealing burst damage to aggressive foes. With the right materials like Smoldering Butterflies and Mushroom, these become one of the most consistent offensive tools.

3. Magic Grease

Magic Grease can be crafted early on and used to buff your weapon with magic damage. It gives melee players a way to punch through armor or enemies weak to sorcery, all without needing to buy expensive consumables. It’s a great example of how crafting offers more value than store-bought buffs.

4. Preserving Boluses

Crafting your own status-clearing items is not only practical but necessary for surviving in rot-infested areas like Caelid. Preserving Boluses cleanse Scarlet Rot, a status effect that can be fatal if left unchecked. Crafting them yourself saves you from hunting down overpriced stock.

5. Sleepbone Arrows

While merchants rarely stock sleep-inducing projectiles in useful quantities, crafting Sleepbone Arrows gives you a steady supply. They’re surprisingly effective in PvP and certain PvE fights—especially when used to isolate enemies or create a short window for a critical hit.

6. Holy Water Pots

Crafted using Silver Tear Husk and other materials, Holy Water Pots are particularly effective against undead enemies like skeletons. They deal holy damage and can often prevent enemies from reanimating. These are far more reliable than the rare holy damage items you’ll find at vendors.

7. Neutralizing Boluses

Poison is everywhere in Elden Ring, and Neutralizing Boluses are a must-have when delving into swamps and poisoned dungeons. Buying them is rarely efficient. Crafting them ensures you’re always stocked without wasting cheap elden ring runes that are better saved for leveling.

8. Freezing Grease

Freezing Grease adds frost damage to your weapons, which not only chips away at HP but also reduces enemy stamina regeneration upon build-up. In high-stakes fights, it offers a better return than most buff items you’ll find in shops, especially when you need fast burst potential.

9. Beast Lure Pot

An underappreciated tool, Beast Lure Pots attract animal-type enemies and can help you reposition or trap beasts during dungeon runs. Crafting a few before heading into wild territory gives you strategic options without relying on vendor stock, which often lacks variety.

10. Staunching Boluses

Bleed effects from enemies or PvP invaders can end fights fast. Staunching Boluses stop blood loss buildup and can be life-saving in key battles. Rather than burning your hard-earned cheap Elden Ring Items, it’s far more practical to carry a stack of these homemade defenses.


Why Crafting Beats Shopping in Elden Ring

Crafting in Elden Ring isn't just a side system—it’s a game-changing way to stay stocked with powerful, situational tools. When you rely solely on merchants, you not only limit your options but also burn through your resources faster. Crafting allows you to convert common materials into potent advantages while saving your cheap elden ring runes for upgrades or rare items.

The next time you're browsing a merchant’s wares, ask yourself: do I need this, or can I make something better?


Quick Reply Box
You must be logged in to reply to the thread.
-->